Monday, April 25, 2011

And You Thought I Was Done!

I just finished reading an article that my intern supervisor sent me and I have to say that I am shocked! Literally, no intelligent ideas or witty comments are formed in my head. Here is the article: http://www.nytimes.com/2011/04/24/nyregion/paul-brodeur-battles-new-york-library-over-archives.html?pagewanted=1&_r=1. You have to read it.

The first thing that I thought of was why does he want the items back when he plans to place them in a backyard shed in Cape Cod? I am confused. Collections are meant to be shared and USED!!!!! So why just toss another chance for usage away???? I understand that he can sees it as an insult that the library wants to return some items that the library archives no longer wants after a long period of time but why not take those “rejected” items to a smaller university (college), library or archival deposit? Why the drastic measures? If the collection is returned, all that history will literally go away (the materials will be damaged and eventually break down).

While collections should always be properly weeded and the items not needed for the collection be immediately returned, I understand that curators see and value different things. It sounds like the original woman had a plan to keep all of his items (whether there ever was a finding aid or not is another head pounding experience), but the new curator is looking to reevaluate the collection and see what items are being used versus what items are not. Thus, they could be returned to help open up more space for new collections that would bring in more researchers and hopefully more funding to aid in the daily operations of the archives. Yet in this age when archives and libraries are looking at issues with staffing, budget cuts and funding issues, donors (especially living ones) should be made to feel that their collection is valued. While donors should never be continuously catered to, after all archivist and curators are professionals and have been trained for their job (you would not go to your tax accountant and tell him to keep this receipt and get rid of that receipt, you would let him or her describe what is a tax credit and what is not… so let us start treating archivists and curators in the same way), they do require time and attention. After all, one happy donor can lead to ten possible collection acquisitions while one miserable donor can lead to constant headaches and ten possible new collections going to another archival deposit. Just think about the last time you went to a bad restaurant or store, how many people did you inform and imagine how many more people they told. There needs to be a healthy relationship between both the donor and archivist. Part of that relationship is that the curator honestly most state that while this piece of paper is interesting to the donor, reproductions of articles that can be found in the library and even the world wide web will not help lure in researchers who might be interested in studying and writing on some of the more serious (and primary) documents in the collection. Likewise, the donor can take his or her reproductions and either personally keep them or toss them. A donor-archivist relationship is still an area that needs time and attention so that a uniformed response and plan of action can be drafted, taught and utilized. However, all donors should realize that while you may think your reproductions of your high school essay may be important, you should know that it is only important to you. Originals are supreme and only in the case of an original not being available (due to damage, destruction or because its lost/missing) then a photocopy will be sufficient. After all, would you rather look at and study the original Pride and Prejudice manuscript or a duplicate of it (where the notes and scratches and misspellings have been removed and touched up). Think about it. Anyway, I am more upset that this individual wants to place this stuff in a shed and let it rot then share it with future generations.

No comments:

Post a Comment