Hey Readers,
I read this incredible article last week and decided to write some of my thoughts on it. The article was really interesting and it got my head thinking. Archives always seem to have one major problem: we exist to be used and yet, there is a lot of work involved to make sure that archives are user friendly. In other words, how can an archive exist and operate if the staff is unaware of the items within its collection and if the staff has no idea what is in a collection, then how can they reach out and market the archives to researchers. This problem sounds like the same and timeless question (problem) about whether the chicken or the egg came first. The reason I am equating the two is that both camps passionately argue their side and still we are left with more questions than answers.
The problem is that if archive staff members spend too much time dealing with each item on an individual basis, then they will have to deal with mad donors, researchers and institutions. The old saying that time is money is vital in the case of archives but should a staff quickly rush open a collection to researchers while failing to truly understand the nature, breadth and depth of the collection ( as well as failing to properly treat and/ or preserve items in the collection). This is an age old question and one that an archivist seeks to answer. After all, archives exist because they are to be used. It seems that both authors of the article suggest that archive staff members should review (scan) the items to see if there are any items that need advance treatment or need to stay away from items before they further contaminate a collection. However, the authors believe that staff members should not waste their time going through each item to remove paper clips or staples, so that the collection can be quickly (roughly) assembled, announced (and advertised) and researchers can start to utilize its resources. They mention that a rough copy of a finding aid or even a collector’s itemized list can be used by scholars. Thus, the problem seems to be half solved with this solution.
However, some archives or institutions believe that first they should understand each individual part of the collection so that they can then construct a thorough finding aid and comfortably invite researchers to the archive. This approach can take years and while it does over all offer a more complete understanding of the value and richness of a collection it can cost an archive or institution donors, scholars and even collectors. The authors of the article also point out that while these places appear to have strict preservation guidelines, they often fail to adhere to them and in some cases some of the surveyed archives still were working on regulating humidity and temperature in their collections rooms. Thus, it seems that both groups have partial solutions or good intentions but no one yet is truly able to solve this problem. Either archives quickly process and assemble a collection which can be used immediately or they take years to assemble the collection and risk alienating donors, scholars and collectors in the process (maybe even cause the institution that houses the archive to question its continued existence).
This was really an awesome article and I am looking forward to discussing it with my intern supervisor this week. I really only had one question. Why or when were archive folders created? The article asks why archivists are not utilizing plain manila folders and instead using these specific folders. They raise an interesting question and I am trying to figure out why manila envelopes were discounted or what events caused them to be discontinued or never utilized.
No comments:
Post a Comment